Gross Margin (%) = (Hasil – COGS) ÷ Hasil × 100
This formula look simple. But for platform seller, even the meaning of revenue now becoming complicated.
Platform seller may face several deductions: commission fee, transaction fee, platform support fee, affiliate commission, advertising, vouchers and seller-funded promotions. TikTok Shop Malaysia, for example, officially lists category-based commission, a 3.78% transaction fee and RM0.54 platform support fee per completed order. Shopee Malaysia also imposes commission, a 3.78% transaction fee and platform support fee. (TikTok Shop)
When everything stacked together, our actual deductions for certain sales or campaigns can approach 40%.
Seller may record RM100 sales, but perhaps only RM60 finally enter the bank. The remaining RM40 was never available for salaries, inventory replacement or business expansion.
Under IFRS 15, however, whether revenue should be reported gross or net depend on whether the business act as a principal or agen. A principal normally recognises gross revenue and records platform fees separately as expenses. An agen normally recognises only its fee or commission. Therefore, simply changing accounting revenue to the platform settlement amount may not always be technically correct. (IFRS Asas)
But for PKS management, relying only on gross sales can create wrong picture.
A seller may show strong revenue but very weak cash retained. Then seller performance look bad, as if we fail to maintain margin, while large portion already taken by platform before money reach us.
Perhaps PKS need two separate measurements:
Perakaunan Hasil = Gross sales recognised under the applicable accounting treatment
Actual Seller Hasil = GMV – refunds – platform charges – seller-funded promotions
Then calculate an internal margin:
Seller Margin (%) = (Actual Seller Hasil – COGS) ÷ Actual Seller Hasil × 100
The pressure is not only margin.
PKS must download settlement reports, separate many fee types, match every order, reconcile refunds and prepare proper tax records. Too much manpower used just to understand how much we actually earned, when PKS supposed to focus on improving produk and increasing sales.
Malaysia’s tax authority confirms that e-commerce business income is taxable, but tax is generally based on taxable business income-not simply the amount displayed as marketplace GMV. Proper records of income and related business expenses still required. (lampiran2.hasil.gov.my)
The issue is not asking platform to operate for free.
The issue is transparency.
Every platform should provide one standard statement clearly separating:
GMV → Refunds → Platform Fees → Promotion Costs → Net Settlement
Without this, PKS may look successful based on sales figure, while the bank account telling a very different story.
